17

Finding innovative funding

How inspiring women founders and investors are turning the tide

Why we need multiple flavours of capital for inclusive gender-smart business

Why we need multiple flavours of capital for inclusive gender-smart business

Interview with Suzanne Biegel, Founder of Catalyst at Large, Co-founder of GenderSmart

The definition of gender lens investing (GLI) is quite broad. Do you think it should be more specifically defined, with certain quantified targets, or do you think there is value in allowing for a range of approaches?

Let’s start with that definition for clarity’s sake: gender-smart investing is the integration of gender analysis into the investment process for better social and financial outcomes. This includes investing in women founders, but goes far beyond that. There’s gender analysis to be done across the entire supply and value chain, from the customers to the impact on the community, whether you’re investing in private or public companies, early or later stage. How are you really looking at gender factors within any business?

There is value in defining specific key performance indicators (KPIs) around the impact you’re trying to have – including women on boards or number of women funded. But if we want to have a transformational impact on women, and through that on the world, we need to allow for multiple approaches in tandem that fit a diversity of starting points and needs – even if this makes measurement more complex.

You recently released the gender lens investing report Project Sage 3.0. The research indicated a significant increase in GLI globally, from an initial focus in the United States. Can you explain the reasons behind this shift and expansion to other regions?

A growing number of investors and entrepreneurs now recognise that gender is material to financial, business, and social outcomes, and that ignoring gender and other factors of identity in their investments and businesses exposes them to financial risk. This could be in terms of access to talent, markets, or the innovation that comes from diverse thought. Women represent an undervalued market opportunity.

In addition, traditional financing such as bank debt and venture capital (VC) is sometimes the wrong fit for women entrepreneurs building inclusive gender-smart businesses. We need different flavours of capital. Investing directly into companies is also only one route – it can be more efficient and effective for investors to invest through intermediated vehicles (funds.) So in Project SAGE we saw a lot of new funds come out to fill this gap, creating structured ways for the right kinds of capital to move into companies.

Some investors are very intentionally trying to stimulate the market. In Southeast Asia, for example, DFAT Investing in Women launched a dedicated program to get more fund managers investing with a gender lens. In addition to capital, they got operational and strategic support, access to pipeline, and exposure. (Others, including DFC in the US and the African Women’s Leadership Fund, are taking a similar approach.)

It’s also worth noting the role of storytelling and communication in the growth of gender finance – we and many other ecosystem builders have done our bit to share success stories, solid data and compelling case studies, which all help to make the case for investing with a gender lens.

African woman manufacturing hats
Gender lens investing helps women entrepreneurs scale their businesses.
© GIZ/Michael Tsigaye

What do you see as the main challenges faced by women entrepreneurs and women-focused enterprises in securing funding to scale their inclusive businesses?

One is access to the right kind of investor networks. A second is that, if they have a truly inclusive business which doesn’t yet have the financial returns profile of classic venture capital, then they might need to find blended capital solutions, outcomes based financing, or funds looking to back normal growth businesses. The third is that they need to be sure that they're ready for outside capital. Do they have the right processes and systems in place, and understand how to position themselves to attract investment?

What advice would you have for women entrepreneurs who are having trouble explaining their value to investors because they have unique inclusive business models with performance indicators that may not be as easily measured monetarily?

You've got to figure out what you can measure, and then figure out what proxies you have to demonstrate evidence of traction and impact. You should have the usual traction metrics like revenue, repeat customers, cost of customer acquisition. Then from an impact standpoint, some investors will ask for very specific KPIs and how you're going to measure them. Other investors might be more interested in the stories you can tell to demonstrate a positive impact on your audience, which narratives you use. It’s worth looking at lean data providers like 60 Decibels, as well as consultants like Kore Global (and others) who focus on the storytelling aspect.

What effect has the Covid-19 pandemic had on gender lens investing, from your experience and research?

It's set back gender-smart entrepreneurs and fund managers tremendously because people are so focused on just surviving. Investors had existing businesses to support, and also had to pause any new deals because they couldn’t complete due diligence. Businesses on a healthy growth trajectory pre-COVID have had to pivot.

Women have also taken on a lot of the care burden, whether their kids are out of school, or because people were getting sick, and that created huge time poverty. This has been well documented, as has the fact that women are more likely to work in the businesses that were most affected by the pandemic, whether retail, hospitality, or teaching.

On the flip side, the businesses that were able to pivot and go digital, actually grew because there was so much more demand. So it's not a universally bad story. The other positive is that the world has woken up to the issues that women (and especially women of colour) are disproportionately facing, and there’s an increased focus on tackling those challenges using investment and other tools like policy.

African woman wearing mask while preparing food
The Covid-19 pandemic has affected gender lens investing. Image: © GIZ / Aude Rossignol

What is important for the future of gender lens investing?

Gender finance is about using investment as a tool for building equity in the world, but increasingly gender lens investors are realising the importance of an intersectional approach, and incorporating new perspectives, to get to true equity. As one delegate at the virtual GenderSmart Investing Summit put it, it’s about speaking to the people who are closest to the issues but furthest away from the power so that the right investment decisions are made. We launched a Justice, Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (JEDI) working group to help investors integrate racial and ethnic equity into gender lens investing, and others are doing the same with LGBTQ+ rights. I believe this is a good thing and will only lead to better financial and social outcomes, but we need to build the capacity of more investors and entrepreneurs to do this analysis well.

So it's a combination of changing how we invest and changing who has a seat at the table. What kinds of insights do we use to determine what a good business opportunity looks like? Investors might not have the data to show them why something is a market opportunity - it’s up to the entrepreneurs to help them get there. And as investors, we need to also be open to different sources of data, whether they are insights from an NGO, women's organisation or a community with local business insight. There’s a role here for translators who can speak both the language of finance, and the language of gender (and other) experts. Criterion Institute are doing some great work in this arena.

We also need to keep convening people who wouldn’t usually be in the same room so they can have those conversations, learn from each other, and move forward to action - from big institutional investors and policymakers to entrepreneurs and academics. Capital networks are hard enough to access for women, especially women of colour: we need to do what we can to broaden the tent.

 

More information: Gendersmartinvesting.com

Suzanne Biegel

Suzanne is founder of Catalyst at Large Ltd and is a globally-recognised expert on gender-smart investing. As Co-Founder of GenderSmart she steers strategy, programming, participation, and communications. She is an adviser to foundations, DFIs, and other institutional investors on gender-smart investing, and is a pioneer with her personal portfolio in this arena.

Podcast

Talking #InclusiveBiz No. 3: Impacting the growth trajectory of women founders through innovative initiatives, such as Global Scale Up X

In the third episode of the iBAN podcast Talking #InclusiveBiz, Susann Tischendorf from iBAN speaks with Jona Repishti and Amanda Epting, Managers at MIT D-Lab, about their inspiring work on solving crucial global gender financing challenges and about…
Susann Tischendorf
Table of contents

graphic summary

GRAPHIC SUMMARY

Learn more about inspiring women entrepreneurs and innovative investors by reading this seventeenth edition of the online magazine on Inclusive Business! The illustration was developed by Christopher Malapitan, a visual practitioner and trainer…

Christopher Malapitan

editorial

Optimism and frustration, celebration and caution: the rising tide of women entrepreneurs taking their place in business and finance

In her editorial, Caroline Ashley discusses why advances in funding for women entrepreneurs provide reasons for both optimism and caution, focusing on both the vibrancy of innovation and new solutions and the work that still remains to close the gap.

Caroline Ashley

feature story

Finding innovative funding: Unlocking capital for women founders

Women founders are building inclusive and innovative businesses that serve the traditionally underserved around the globe. However, many women still struggle to receive the capital they need to grow their businesses. This issue of CLUED-iN features several groundbreaking women business founders, from Ajaita Shah who developed an all-woman sales force in rural India, to Brigitha Faustin, whose sunflower oil is produced mainly by women in Tanzania. It includes a range of insights from entrepreneurs, gender smart investment experts, investors, and women capital allocators, who examine what it will take to narrow the gender funding gap and support women founders around the globe.

Alexandra Harris

Talking #InclusiveBiz No. 3: Impacting the growth trajectory of women founders through innovative initiatives, such as Global Scale Up X

In the third episode of the iBAN podcast Talking #InclusiveBiz, Susann Tischendorf from iBAN speaks with Jona Repishti and Amanda Epting, Managers at MIT D-Lab, about their inspiring work on solving crucial global gender financing challenges and about the importance of incorporating inclusive innovation processes into the work of practitioners. In particular, they highlight why innovative storytelling approaches, like the one of the Global Scale Up X Instagram channel recently launched by MIT D-Lab and iBAN, are important in helping smooth the entrepreneurial journeys of female entrepreneurs.

Why we need multiple flavours of capital for inclusive gender-smart business

Suzanne Biegel, a global leader in gender smart investment, explains how women entrepreneurs can benefit from multiple types of funding. She also discusses the role of storytelling in making the business case for investing in women.

“How much ease can we create?”: Developing financial solutions for rural women

Chetna Gala Sinha founded Mann Deshi Bank and Foundation to help a woman blacksmith in rural India save for a tarpaulin cover. In her interview, she discusses how new financial solutions and credit rating tools should be tailored to women-owned businesses.

Why traditional investment indicators don’t always apply

Nathalie Aldana, who founded a business in Sweden selling dried fruits and jams sourced in Colombia, reveals why inclusive businesses may value performance indicators that don’t directly fit with traditional investment models.

Shifting capital towards women’s economic empowerment

Jessica Espinoza, Chair of the 2X Challenge, explains why investing in funds and platforms that invest in women through gender-smart business is one of the best ways to scale the impact of capital.

Overcoming gender barriers and supporting female farmers in Tanzania

Many investors expect you to spend 100 per cent of your time on your company, says Brigitha Faustin, founder and CEO of OBRI Tanzania. In this interview, she shares how she balanced life and family and how the Tanzanian government supports women founders.

Choosing the right type of funding to make a lasting impact on female artisans

Reese Fernandez-Ruiz discusses scaling and funding for inclusive businesses and how Rags2Riches supports women artisans beyond providing livelihoods in the Philippines.

Creating more tables, not just seats at the table: Narrowing the gender funding gap by investing in women capital allocators

In Africa, there are many startups led by women, but these enterprises often have trouble accessing finance. In her interview, Adesuwa Okunbo Rhodes shares how Aruwa Capital Management opens up funding and opportunities for women entrepreneurs.

Investing in women is smart business and key to poverty alleviation at scale

Ajaita Shah discusses why investing in women has a strong impact on poverty alleviation, and how she has empowered a network of women sales agents in rural India through her enterprise, Frontier Markets.

Empowering women-focused businesses by tying investment to impact assessment

Robert Kraybill explains how IIX developed the first Women’s Livelihood Bond which limits risk for investors and ties investment to impact on women’s livelihoods in multiple countries.

Voices of global female entrepreneurs

Which challenges have female founders tackled, what have they experienced, and what have they learned? In this Voices piece, four successful women entrepreneurs featured in the Impact Stories series share their stories.